Why did the 49ers drop Trey Lance for the season with a broken fibula?

Why did the 49ers drop Trey Lance for the season with a broken fibula?

SANTA CLARA — Kyle Shanahan confirmed what appeared to be clear Wednesday when he said quarterback Trey Lance would be out for the season following surgery to repair a ruptured right fibula with ligament damage.

Good News?

It would be a big surprise if Lance was unable to attend non-contact off-season assignments and then prepare for training camp the following July.

Although Lance’s broken leg will heal before the end of the season, getting him back in motion for a violent confrontation game is another matter. This is the opinion of Dr David Ozzie of Stanford Hospital, an orthopedic surgeon and specialist in ankle injuries.

Ozzy Lance doesn’t know the specifics of surgery other than the 49ers’ statement “Right right fibula torn with ligament disruption,” but has experience treating and operating patients with broken ankles.

“Fractures occur in about two months for these types of injuries. The fracture is fairly stable,” Ozzy said in a phone interview. “It is not completely healed, but there is sufficient healing of the bone that it is mechanically stable. And so is the case with ligaments. Usually, it is fairly stable.”

Bone healing, however, is only the first step in lance rehab—and not necessarily the easiest part.

Ozzy said, “Athletes still have to build muscle and strength and that’s where I think a lot of people don’t realize that sometimes it takes longer to recover than a real break. “

“For someone like you and me, in two months, we’ll probably be able to ride bikes and move around comfortably. But performing at a premier level in the NFL is going to take time.”

In Lance’s case, the two-month deadline for bone healing would be early November, at which point the 49ers would be just past the midpoint of the season.

Then comes preparing the ankle for the rigors of the NFL, which, according to Ozzy, can take more than two months.

Given that Lance is a quarterback who relies heavily on his mobility to be effective, the 49ers’ common sense move was to shut him down. With a more deliberate approach to rehabilitation, Lance would theoretically be ready for off-season events that typically begin in February.

Raiders quarterback Derek Carr broke his right fibula on Christmas Eve in 2016 against the Colts at the Coliseum and was ready for Week 1 in 2017. (Jose Carlos Fajardo / Bay Area Newsgroup)

Complications are rare, according to Ozzy.

“Historically, there are about five to 10 percent of patients with superficial infections, but patients generally do very well with this surgery,” Ozzy said. “It’s pretty standard surgery.”

For a recent example, Raiders quarterback Derek Carr and Tennessee quarterback Marcus Mariota broke their right fibula in Week 16 on Christmas Eve in 2016.

Carr and Mariota both ended up going through the offseason with their respective teams, and each had a ready game at the 2017 opening. In fact, they began the season playing against each other, with the Raiders defeating the Tennessee Titans 26-16.

Neither injury showed any ill effects. Carr completed 22 of 32 passes for 262 yards and two touchdowns, while Mariota, whose playing style more closely mirrored Lance in terms of running ability, passed for 256 yards and including a 10-yard touchdown run. Runs three for 26 yards.

Lance broke his ankle and had 2:33 left in an inside game in the first quarter and had surgery on Monday.

“He’s doing as well as he can,” Shanahan said. “Trey has been great. Lots of guys, we’ve all talked to him a lot. He’s trying to get into the game this week. I don’t think he’ll be able to do that until the swelling subsides, but he’ll soon Will come back and become part of us later.

Linebacker Fred Warner said that Lance was “doing well, in great spirits.”

Shanahan said on Monday that he hopes Lance will do his rehab with the club and will stick to meetings whenever possible.

Jimmy Garoppolo, who agreed to a renegotiated contract to backup Lance on August 29, will take over as the starter on Sunday night against the Denver Broncos.


This News is Published from Google Alert – Trey Lance.

Leave a Reply